Subscribe to Cookie Madness by Email

S’mores Bars

by on June 11, 2007 · 30 comments

S’mores taste best when cooked and assembled among friends and open flames, but today I wanted them in bar cookie form.  Rather than search my cookbooks for a recipe, I searched the Internet and came upon this one from Hershey’s. I could tell by looking at Hershey’s picture that it would fit the bill, so I made it exactly as instructed but lined the pan with non-stick foil so I could lift the bars out and cut them neatly.

Here’s a picture of the base dough. Pretty sturdy looking, eh? Just what I was looking for.


And here’s a cross section after the cookies were baked. This is right out of the oven, so I suspect they’ll be less gooey later and will post another photo when they set.

smores out of the oven.jpg

All in all, this a very good bar cookie. Just watch out because if you go with the milk chocolate (in true S’mores fashion), the bars will be very sweet…sweet as in “Dang Y’all this is sweet!” Then again, we all have different tolerances for sugar. In fact, I think it varies among individuals in accordance with the moon and tides, but that’s neither here nor there…I liked these with the milk chocolate, but next time I’m going to try them with dark chocolate.

The recipe is on Hershey’s site. If they change the link or if it goes away, let me know.

Related posts:

Published on June 11, 2007

{ 30 comments… read them below or add one }

meredith June 11, 2007 at 12:05 pm

Anna – this is the recipe that I found last year after [our] ardous search, too! Let me know what you think — I preferred w/ dark chocolate, but that’s my taste. They go GREAT w/ coffee, but fair warning — you’ll be flying off the walls w/ all of the sugar and caffeine.
P.S.: I want to try the s’mores pie on the Hershey’s site for Father’s Day!

Anna June 11, 2007 at 12:18 pm

Meredith, I remember searching and finding something, but all I remember was it being gooey. Guess that’s why I filed it under “Gooey”. This one is definitely better. I’ve created a S’mores category so that we can refer back to it.

Joe June 11, 2007 at 1:12 pm

How fun! I think this would be great with dark chocolate too.

rebecca June 11, 2007 at 1:39 pm

ooh! i was craving some s’mores just last night. i LOVE that you posted this today.

Carrie June 11, 2007 at 3:43 pm

One flavor element that is missing from the bar is the black burnt part of the marshmallow you get from the fire. Maybe that cuts the sweetness a little in the traditional s’more? Kind of like the difference between baked chicken and grilled chicken.

Anna June 11, 2007 at 3:50 pm

Carrie, I didn’t even think about that. Great point! All the more reason to use dark chocolate since dark chocolate is kind of smoky. I guess using dark chocolate would be easier than burning the marshmallow cream ;).

Anna June 11, 2007 at 3:55 pm

Jami, I used Kraft marshmallow cream — the kind that comes in a jar and costs a little over a dollar. There’s another brand called Marshmallow Fluff which I believe is the same. I don’t think my grocery store carries the “fluff” type, but one day I’m going to hunt it down and try it….Central Market might have it. Sorry, I’m rambling.

BTW. I have a recipe for marshmallow fluff/cream. It doesn’t sound too hard, either. Maybe I’ll make it tomorrow.

Anna June 11, 2007 at 4:17 pm

Carrie’s comment just gave me an idea. I think Kraft or the Marshmallow Fluff people should do a line of marshmallow creme/marshmallow fluff that has char flavor swirled through it. Or wait, that might be kind of icky…but maybe some sort of roasty aroma? It seems like that wouldn’t be too hard to do, right? “New! Roasted Marshmallow Creme!” I’d buy it.

Lindsay June 11, 2007 at 4:32 pm

Do you like these better than your other (from Family Circle) version? (link:

I loved the first version, but if these are better I’ll jump right on them!

Anj June 11, 2007 at 5:04 pm

Man oh man those look good. I love the thought of infusing the ‘char’ taste into the marshmallow cream – what an excellent idea! That’s my favorite part of a roasted marshmallow!

Kim June 11, 2007 at 5:39 pm

Was it difficult to spread the marshmallow cream over the chocolate? Did you have to warm the cream slightly to spread it, or is the consistency OK right out of the jar?

I worry about the weirdest stuff…

Anna June 11, 2007 at 6:06 pm

Lindsay, I’d have to try them side by side. However, I really like these because they aren’t as crumbly. These were sweeter, but there’s an easy fix to that — the dark chocolate.

Kim, good question. If you press the candy bars into the dough, you kind of anchor the chocolate the creme goes on pretty easily. If you used chocolate chips or crumbled up chocolate, it might be more challenging. So I’d say the best way to do it would be to use chocolate in bar form (like the recipe says) and don’t chop it up or anything.

Kristen June 11, 2007 at 9:03 pm

Yay – I can comment :) I love S’mores anything… I will have to give these a try. They sound delicious!

Janet June 12, 2007 at 7:30 am

These look wonderful! I went for rhubarb coffeecake last night since I didn’t have marshmallow creme…will try these soon…thanks.

Anna June 12, 2007 at 7:33 am

I still can’t find fresh rhubarb :(.

Chelsea June 13, 2007 at 2:48 pm

I just took this out of the oven, and I must say it looks delicious! I substituted in chocolate chips and marshmallows, only because I didn’t have fluff or chocolate bars. It still turned out great, I plan to give it to my father for Father’s Day!

Anna June 13, 2007 at 3:31 pm

Hi Chelsea,

Thanks for letting us know that regular marshmallows work. I was worried they might dry out, but I guess the top layer of dough keeps them insulated.

I suppose I need to make my dad something too….

PhillyGirl June 14, 2007 at 9:33 am

Made two batches last night. First batch was made with Fluff and Hershey’s milk choc bars. Had to use Pam on the spatula to get the Fluff to spread. Second batch was Nestle’s Chocolatier dark chocolate bits and big marshmallows. Had to put the second batch in the oven first to soften the marshmallows before putting on the top crust. I lined the pans with Pam and parchment paper and used water on my fingers to help spread the bottom and top crusts. Next time I’ll use about 40% crust on the bottom and 60% on top. My house smelled terrific during baking. I was able to cool then cut them about 30-40 mins out of the oven. As predicted, the Hershey Bar/Fluff batch was sweeter than the dark choc/marshmallow batch. I actually prefered the first one only because my sweetness tolerance is very high. I brought the dark choc batch into work and my co-workers loved them. The Hershey bar batch went to the end-of-year party at school with my 11-year-old. I’m sure they will be bouncing off the walls this afternoon. :) Thanks so much for pointing me to the recipe!!!

Anna June 14, 2007 at 10:31 am


Thanks for the good review. Sweetness tolerance really is a factor here. Again, I’m glad to hear you were successful with the big marshmallows. That was a clever trick you used — putting the marshmallows in the oven to soften them before adding the top crust. I’m going to remember that one.

nicole July 30, 2007 at 2:18 am

This was so yummy. it really tastes like smores. i used dark chocolate and I liked it a lot, it wasnt super sweet but i dont like desserts too sweet so it was perfect for me; and all my company liked it. btw, the marshmallow creme is easy to spread; you dont have to heat it, that would ruin it.

nicole July 30, 2007 at 2:18 am

This was so yummy. it really tastes like smores. i used dark chocolate and I liked it a lot, it wasnt super sweet but i dont like desserts too sweet so it was perfect for me; and all my company liked it. btw, the marshmallow creme is easy to spread; you dont have to heat it, that would ruin it.

nicole July 30, 2007 at 2:18 am

This was so yummy. it really tastes like smores. i used dark chocolate and I liked it a lot, it wasnt super sweet but i dont like desserts too sweet so it was perfect for me; and all my company liked it. btw, the marshmallow creme is easy to spread; you dont have to heat it, that would ruin it.

Anna July 30, 2007 at 7:47 am

Thanks for the comment Nicole! I am always happy to hear when recipes are successful.

Laura October 8, 2007 at 7:09 pm

I just made these for a bake sale. I had to have one (just to make sure!) and they were delicious. I don’t know how I managed to have just one…I’m sure they’ll be a huge hit tomorrow. Thanks for a great recipe!

Jen February 12, 2008 at 6:19 pm

Just an FYI…these bars taste EVEN better when substituting the regular hershey’s chocolate with 2 giant hershey’s symphony bars (with the toffee and almonds included in the bars)and using 1/2 cup regular sugar and 1/4 cup brown sugar instead of the 3/4 reg sugar(I’m always a fan of adding some brown sugar to just about anything!) Oh yeah, and use the whole container of the marshmallow creme, you can never go wrong with a little more! (can you tell I’ve made these a few times!?)

Nicole March 18, 2008 at 8:26 pm

I made these for my family… brothers, sisters, and all our kids… everyone liked them but i feel like i overbaked them slightly (but i like things more doughy) anyway, they are great and i will make them again. I used a 9×9 glass pan – worked great!

Krisma July 23, 2008 at 1:26 am

I actually put this recipe on my not-too-organized blog. It’s a smorgasbord of personal blogs, book blogs, and food blogs. I’m just starting out so it’s a little too plain now. But I can’t wait till I try this recipe! It looks so yummy and I have a treat to give to my boyfriend tomorrow!

Thanks for the tip about controlling the sweetness. I hate it when desserts are too sweet cause I end up eating all of them. Hahaha. But thanks so much! Can’t wait to try this recipe!

I love your site, btw! :]

Jennifer September 14, 2008 at 12:22 pm

Loved these!!! Can’t stop eating them, so glad to find such a great, easy delicious dessert!

Kelley June 7, 2009 at 7:31 pm

I was reading through the comments and noticed that everyone agreed these are excellent but would be much better if you could capture that ‘burnt marshmallow taste’….problem solved! i ripped the larger marshmallows in half and made a layer over the fluff then added the dough to the top but the mallows stuck out and when i cooked them they camae out with a nice golden brown top!!! worth a try…yum!

ashley h December 17, 2009 at 5:18 am

my family loves when i make this. 1st time i ever made it i burned it, and it wasnt good, but after that, ive made it a lot more times and ive always made sure not to burn it and its so so so so so good. Definitly one of my very favorite recipes ever

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post: