Election Day Peanut Butter Cookies

Last week I wrapped up a few of my favorite peanut butter cookies and gave them to a friend. The next day she told me they were too rich. This was unsettling, because as you know, I think that’s the best peanut butter cookie ever. After mulling it over, I decided that my friend was using “too rich” for “too peanut buttery”. Maybe she just needed a cookie with a milder peanut butter flavor?

So I had my friend in mind this morning when I saw the peanut butter cookie from the Dallas Morning News article I linked to earlier. The recipe is from the book Presidential Cookies and the peanut butter cookie is what the Carter family kept in their boot shaped cookie jar….or so the story goes. At any rate, a peanut butter cookie approved by Jimmy Carter had to be good enough for me!

I wasn’t crazy about the shortening, but shortening does give cookies a good texture so I decided to go with it. Other changes were minor. I halved the recipe, increased the salt, added a little vanilla and wrapped the cookies around Reese’s peanut butter cups. Okay, not so minor, but definitely good! This was a good all-purpose peanut butter cookie dough mild enough for kids, easy to work with (after chilling) and perfect for mixing with leftover Halloween candy.

Reese\'s stuffed peanut butter cookies

Election Day Peanut Butter Cookies

4 tablespoons unsalted butter (room temperature)
4 tablespoons shortening
1/4 cup chunky or smooth peanut butter (chunky)
1/2 cup granulated sugar
1/2 cup light brown sugar, packed
1/2 scant teaspoon salt
1/2 teaspoon vanilla
1 large egg
1/2 teaspoon baking soda
2 tablespoons warm water
1 1/2 cups sifted flour (about 6 oz)
10 Reese’s peanut butter cups (the larger flat type)
3 tablespoons Reese’s Pieces

Don’t preheat oven quite yet.

Cream butter, shortening and peanut butter together in a mixing bowl; Beat in granulated and light brown sugar, salt and vanilla. Beat in egg.

Dissolve baking soda in warm water. Add to butter-sugar mixture and stir well. Stir in flour. Mix until dough is smooth. Wrap dough in plastic wrap and refrigerate 1 hour or until dough is firm enough to be workable.

Roll dough by hand into golf ball size balls. Working one ball at a time, split ball in half, place a Reese’s in between halves and mold dough around candy to make a neat mound. Press a few Reese’s pieces on top

Arrange on ungreased cookie sheets, leaving 1 to 2 inches between cookies. Bake at 350 degrees F. 15 minutes or until golden brown. Let cookies stand 10 minutes before transferring to wire racks to cool completely. Store in a tightly covered container.

Makes about 10 big cookies

Related posts:


  1. Veronica says

    I love the peanut butter cup in the middle…they would be favorites of my girl-she loves peanut butter.

  2. pat says

    Hi Anna,

    Which recipe are you referring to as your favorite? I need to try a new one and certainly trust your judgment as to which is the best. Thanks.

  3. Sue says

    Don’t let that review of your favorites unsettle you. Those cookies were loved by everyone who tasted them when I made them, and that recipe is now the go to PB cookie at my house.

  4. says

    Too rich? For me they’re just too right, lol! Maybe your friend needed less pb for her taste, I bet she’ll like these! I also liked your “minor” changes to the recipe ahahah!

  5. says

    these look great!!! i love the whole Reese’s theme. my best friend’s fav candy is Reese’s. i’m not gonna lie- they are very good, but my heart goes to almond joy 🙂

  6. Catherine says

    yikes! i think maybe your friend should have just said “thank you” 🙂

    you can send me cookies anytime!!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *