This recipe is from a book called The Perfect Recipe Baking Book: 50 Foolproof Recipes for America’s Classic Cakes, Pies, Cookies, and More by the late Murray Jaffe.
I’d never heard of Mr. Jaffe until I found his book in the Pleasant Hill library, but I wish I could have met him. He made his fortune helping his 17 year old daughter Barbara start a baking company in 1971. They named it Barbara’s Bakery, and after running the company for many years sold it to Weetabix. Barbara and Murray remained very passionate home bakers, and during his retirement Murray wrote this cookbook citing Barbara as his inspiration. In it are the 50 recipes he saved over the years and which of course, he believed were perfect.
This brownie recipe was Murray’s idea of perfection and in the intro he states that he must have tried 50 brownies recipes before stopping at this one. With an endorsement like that, how could I resist?
One interesting thing to note is that Murray Jaffe’s Perfect Brownies require a good beating *after* the addition of flour. The success of so many baked goods hinges on stirring the flour gently after adding and not over strengthening the gluten with beating. But with brownies, you want to strengthen the gluten a bit to give them some chew. In this recipe Murray mentions how important that is, and he is right! Beating the batter after adding the flour makes the texture more like box brownies.
So if you want a brownie with the texture of a box and the flavor of homemade, Murray’s recipe is perfect.
And flavor is important as texture, of course! Because the chocolate flavor comes from cocoa, your brownies will be only as good as the cocoa you use. However, I can tell you that if you break out the “every day” cocoa, you’ll still get awesome brownies. These are chewy on the outside, thick and soft in the center.
Meanwhile, if you can get your hands on a copy of this book consider yourself lucky. It’s been out of print for a while, but Murray Jaffe was ahead of his time as a home baker. Every recipe has an intro, but his advice on kitchen scales, salted vs. unsalted butter, types of cookware, weights of eggs, is progressive for cookbooks of that time. Or at least in terms of home baking.
Perfect Recipe Baking Book -- Murray Jaffe's Perfect Brownies
- 4 ounces 1 stick salted butter, room temperature **
- 1 1/2 cups granulated sugar
- 2 large eggs room temperature
- 1/2 cup plus 1 tablespoon cocoa – measure then sift after measuring
- 1 cup plus 2 tablespoons all purpose flour
- 1/2 teaspoon baking powder
- 1/4 teaspoon salt **
- 1 tablespoon water
- 1 teaspoon vanilla
- 3/4 cup coarsely chopped toasted walnuts
- Line an 8 inch square metal pan with foil and spray bottom with cooking spray.
- Preheat oven to 350 degrees F. Position rack to center.
- In a large bowl, beat the butter until creamy. Beat in the sugar until mixed in. Beat in the eggs (just until mixed -- don't beat in a lot of air), then add the cocoa and mix until smooth. Thoroughly blend together the flour, baking powder and salt. Add to the mixing bowl and beat for 2 minutes (important ). Add the water and vanilla and mix, then mix in the walnuts. Dough will be stiff and sticky.
- Spread dough in pan and bake for 30 40 minutes (I baked for 30) or until a toothpick inserted in the center comes out without batter on it.
- Let cool for a few hours, then lift from pan and cut into 16 squares.
I just bought this book because the brownies look so yummy and you recommended it!!! Thanks! Do you have any favorite bundt cake recipes you have on your blog? I looked for a place to search for recipes and couldn’t find a place to search. I love your blog! Thank you!
Rhonda in OK
I baked these yesterday, used Hersheys cocoa, baked the recipe exactly as published.
they are a great everyday brownie. Thank you!
These look very good….did you use Ghiradelli Cocoa or dutch process or Hershey’s? Thanks for the recipe!
Dr. House isn’t real????
I made these last night (using unsalted butter + ~1/2 tsp. salt and no nuts) and they are definitely pretty near perfect brownies. You are right on by saying they have the texture of box brownies (in a good way) but the taste of homemade. My hubby said they taste like the brownie bites from the bakery at Hannaford (our supermarket up here), which is a good thing! This will definitely be a go-to recipe for when I want a good classic brownie, but not something really fudgy. I really like how thick the brownies are and how they get a nice “crust” on top.
Gloria – mine had a crisp, slightly crinkly top, but not shiny. Lina – If you want to really taste the salt, I’d maybe add even a little more then specified. I found the salt level to taste normal, without a noticeable salt taste.
Thats an interesting take on the double salt (butter + extra 1/4 tsp). I think it will add a new dimension to these brownies. YUMMM
the blissful baker
i love chewy, fudgy brownies! i’ll have to try this recipe to see if these brownies are indeed perfect 🙂
I wonder what they would be like with out blending for 2 minutes? I don’t want to potentially waste good ingredients to find out! Or maybe adding 1/2 small mashed banana? Did they have the shiny crinkly top or more of a crisp top? I know, so many questions!
They look delicious and easy to make!
anna i’m experimenting with brownie pancakes. ever try this? do email me if you have! LOL!!!
I found a used copy of the book on amazon.com for $7.20 with $3.99 shipping. There were other sellers who had copies as well – some went as high as $60+ for a hard bound copy. I’m haven’t ordered a baking book in a long time so I’m really excited! Not much room on my bookcase but I’ll find a space for it 🙂
You find the best books!
I am convinced that brownies make everything better.
I am right… right?
The Chicago Public Library has a copy, I just put it on hold, thanks for the recommendation!
These look delicious! Do you think they will still taste as good if I don’t bother with toasting the walnuts?
Sorry you had some annoying things going on. I hope the brownies helped! They sure do look good!
I recently bought a new cookbook by a famous author and since it’s a cookbook not a baking book I didn’t look to see if it had weights in it. Of course the first thing I made was a baked item and sure enough. No weights. And my results were less than perfect, although still very tasty. I am very disappointed in this author. It makes me especially proud of Mr. Jaffe for being ahead of his time and using scales and weights of ingredients. It makes so much difference! If I ever see that book I’m snapping up!!
Jess @ Bakericious
salted butter + salt, sound interesting and looks tempting, yummy.
A good batch of brownies will always solve any problem and these look like they’d brighten anyone’s day. They really do look fudgy, chewy, and everything a brownie should be.
Cindy, I figure if it’s not on the website, then it’s not available. I’ve noticed rewards are suddenly harder to take advantage of. Then again, I’m looking at Spring Break Texas to Orlando so that may be the problem right there.
I’ll see what I can do about the St. Lucia ad.
Did you try calling Southwest? I had to call last time I wanted to book a reward flight.
And not to make your day worse, but that St. Lucia ad/audio pop up on your website is VERY annoying. Plus I’d never go to St. Lucia because my brother broke his leg on his honeymoon there (!) and medical services were non-existent.
Shannon, that’s correct. Murray uses salted butter plus 1/4 teaspoon salt. I only had unsalted so I used just barely a 1/2 teaspoon total. I could taste the salt a tiny, tiny, bit. However, I liked it. It was a good salty (offset the 1 1/2 cups sugar!) and not bad salty. To be safe, I’d use a good brand of salted butter next time and stick with the 1/4 tsp.
Is that correct – salted butter + salt? These sound good and I have everything to make them, but I don’t want overly salty brownies…