Earlier this week I made a test batch of some cat cookies I thought would be cute for the Halloween party. As I mixed the dough, I had a flashback. I did indeed make these cookies a few years ago and accidentally put the candy corn on the cats before baking. Results were disastrous. However, done properly, these are too cute. I’m glad I waited a couple of years and tried again.
What’s cool is these are as sturdy as they look in the picture. The recipe is adapted from Taste of Home and also appears on allrecipes.com.
Black Cat Cookies on a Stick
8 ounces butter, soft
2 cups granulated sugar
2 large eggs
3 teaspoons vanilla extract
3 cups flour
1 cup unsweetened cocoa powder
1/2 teaspoon baking powder
1/2 teaspoon baking soda
1/2 teaspoon salt
Preheat oven to 350 degrees F and line a couple of cookie sheets with Release foil or parchment.
Cream butter and sugar with mixer. Beat in eggs and vanilla. Combine the flour, cocoa powder, baking powder, baking soda and salt and stir into butter mixture. Shape dough into 1 ½ inch balls and place 3 inches apart on cookie sheets. Insert sticks.
Press down with bottom of sugared glass (I used my hand) to make a circle. Use fork tines to make whiskers. Pinch tops to make ears. Bake at 350 degrees for 10-12 minutes. Remove from oven and immediately decorate as pictured with candy corn. Use red candy for nose. Cool on cookie sheet for a few minutes, then transfer to wire rack to finish cooling.
Makes 24.
Made these for my family’s cookie exchange. WHAT A HIT!!!!
Hi Lourdes,
Thanks for the feedback. If you liked this one, you should buy Taste of Home’s annual Halloween special edition next year. It always has such good ideas.
Also, thanks for letting me know that the egg sub worked. That means that these could easily be made vegan.
Hello! I made these cookies for my son’s halloween party at Sunday school. They were such a big hit. He has an egg allergy. I used the enrgyx egg substitue. They turned out just perfectly.
Some of the kids did not like the candy corn or the red candies. I think I may use M&M’s next time.
Hi Hannah,
Thanks for commenting and also, for letting everyone know you can slip in some whole wheat flour. I hope your family enjoys the cats.
I read your blog regularly but I think this is the first time I’ve commented. I just made the cat cookies (without sticks–and with half whole-wheat flour), and they are so cute! Thanks for the recipe. I can’t wait to share them with my family.
I have my last batch baking right now! I made a few changes since I was making them for snack for school. The snacks are supposed to be healthy so I will take some fruit to go with these. I used 2c whole wheat flour and 1c unbleached flour and I used organic sugar. The flavor is great. I had to test one to make sure they were ok…lol! I used my small cookie scoop which gave me 36 cats and 16 cookies (flattened with a fork like peanut butter cookies).
absolutely too adorable.
Those black cat cookies are the cutest!!! I love this recipe site. I have many recipes to check out. Yea!!!
OMG!!!! I just stumbled onto your site while browsing and WOW!! You have an amazing collection of beautiful cookies and desserts!!
You have a new fan and blog reader 🙂
~Lewis
TableBread
this is definitely one of the most adorable cookies I have ever seen – this batch was certainly a success!! :0)
Steph, I’m going to collect a bunch of Girl Scout Cookie recipes before the season starts.
Brenda, you poke the sticks in before you bake, but you put the candy on after.
What’s great about these cookies is, aside from being sturdy, they taste great.
Very cute. I will make them for the kids across the street.
I’m going to make these for our next snack turn at school! I didn’t see when you put the stick in. Is it before or after you bake?
I’ve been MIA and just caught up.
Regarding your thinking about uses for girl scout cookies – icebox pie crusts. I have a friend who adores chocolate icebox pie and mint, so I made her the pie with a Thin Mint crust. Very tasty.
I am totally going to do this for my kids classrooms. I think the kids will love them! Thanks for the great idea!