Black Magic Forest Cake is basically a Hershey's Black Magic Cake which I turned into a Black Forest Cake by adding cherry filling and whipped cream topping. I'm part German, but alas this is not an authentic cake but rather the “Black Forest” we’re used to in the USA. It doesn't call for Kirschwasser or any type liqueur, and I'll bet it's a lot sweeter than any cake you'd find in Germany.
With or Without Kirschwasser
No matter the origin, everyone has their own interpretation of Black Forest Cake, and it’s fun to see what’s out there. Most versions use a cherry brandy called Kirschwasser, while some leave it out and just use whipped cream and cherries. The richest of the cakes have brandy, cherries, whipped cream and a butter & sugar icing. A couple of years ago I tried one of the more "authentic" versions from allrecipes.com, and while we liked it, the alcohol seemed a bit strong.
After making this cake, I’ve decided I should probably make more Black Forest Cakes. But this is what I have for now – an easy stir-and-bake "Black Magic Cake" filled with cherry filling and covered in whipped cream. I put some notes on the bottom to help you along should you decided to make this version.
A Few Black Forest Cake Notes
This makes a standard 8-inch or 9-inch round layer cake. The filling recipe makes quite a bit, so you'll have plenty for the filling and more to spread on the top. If you want to save money on canned cherries, you can make half of the filling.
Someone in the comments asked what a cake lifter was. Here's a link to one. I use it not only as a cake lifter, but as a spatula and a bench scraper.
Half Cake
As mentioned, the photo at the top is a half cake. I just made half the cake in an 8-inch square pan, split it in two and filled with cherry filling, then frosted with whipped cream. It was fine back when I made it, but I think now I'd halve the recipe and divide it between two 6-inch pans. They are a lot easier to come by than they were when I first posted this recipe. And a 6-inch layer cake is usually more than enough for two.
Recipe
Black Magic Forest Cake
Ingredients
Cherry Filling:
- 2 cans pitted sour cherries (14.5 oz to 16 oz each)
- 1 cup granulated sugar
- ¼ cup cornstarch
- 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
- ⅛ teaspoon almond extract optional
Cake:
- 1 cup milk
- 1 tablespoon vinegar malt, white, cider -- any kind
- 1 ¾ cups all-purpose flour 7.9 oz
- 2 cups granulated sugar
- ¾ cup unsweetened cocoa powder natural style
- 1 teaspoon baking powder
- 2 teaspoons baking soda
- ½ teaspoon salt
- 2 eggs
- ½ cup vegetable oil
- 1 cup strong brewed coffee warm or cold (not hot)
- 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
Whipped Cream:
- 3 cups heavy whipping cream
- ⅓ cup confectioners’ sugar
- 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
Instructions
- Make Filling First: Drain cherries, reserving ½ cup liquid. Combine the ½ cup liquid, 1 cup sugar and cornstarch in a saucepan. Cook over medium heat, stirring constantly, until mixture boils. Let mixture boil, stirring constantly, until it thickens to the consistency of thick maple syrup. Remove from heat and stir in the vanilla, almond extract and drained cherries Let cool at room temperature then transfer to refrigerator and chill for about 2 hours or until ready to assemble.
- Cake: Preheat oven to 350 degrees F. Grease two 8x2 inch cake pans and line with circles of parchment paper (or wax paper). Grease again and dust with flour.
- Combine milk and vinegar in a mixing bowl and set aside for a few minutes to sour the milk.
- Meanwhile, sift the flour, sugar, cocoa powder, baking soda, baking powder and salt together in a second bowl. Mix well to mash out any stray lumps of cocoa powder.
- Add the eggs, oil, coffee and vanilla to the bowl with the milk/vinegar mixture and whisk well. Stir in the flour mixture and beat by hand about 50 strokes or until mixed -- batter will be thin and lumpy. There shouldn’t be big chunks of cocoa powder, though.
- Pour batter into prepared pans and set the pans on a cookie sheet to catch any spills. Bake for 30 -35 minutes, or until a toothpick inserted into the center of the cake comes out clean – stick the toothpick right in the center to test, this cake might seem done, but you won't know for sure unless you test it. Cool 10 minutes in pan, then turn from pans onto racks. Peel away parchment or wax paper rounds and let cool completely.
- Whipped Cream: Beat whipping cream in a large bowl until soft peaks form. Beat in the sugar and vanilla and continue beating until peaks are stiff.
- Assemble Cake: With long serrated knife, split each cake layer horizontally in half. Tear one split layer into crumbs and set aside. For finer crumbs, you can pulse the cake layer in the food processor. These will be used as garnish.
- Place one cake layer on cake plate. Spread with a little whipped cream; top with about ¾ cup cherry topping. Top with second cake layer; repeat layers of whipped cream and cherry topping. Top with third cake layer. Frost side of cake with remaining whipped cream. Pat reserved crumbs onto frosting on side of cake or if you want, just use them on the top as pictured. Arrange a bit more filling on top in a decorative way. Chill cake until ready to serve.
Hannelore Hevesy says
Hello Dani:
The cake derives its name from the Black Forest region in southwest Germany where I'm from and it's my favorite cake also. It's a beautiful area and it's called "Black" because the trees are predominantly pines and thus it looks darker than with leafy trees mixed in. I'll try this version, it sounds great. I use some Kirschwasser but not too much so my grandkids can enjoy it too. The Kirschwasser (literally translates as cherry water) from Germany is traditionally made in the Black Forest region and "wasser" in this sense means "Schnapps" (kind of like a German Tequila). By the way, Schnapps is often used by the grownups to settle their stomachs and as for me, Mama always put it on my skinned knees as an antibiotic and it was truly an ouch thing, I'd rather enjoy it in the cake. Guten Appetit!
Dani says
mmmm, my sister and I just made THE MOST DELICIOUS black forest cake the other night for my dad.......oooooooooh so good.
Funny thing is, it isnt "black" in any way - the cake is kinda light colored =)
But this is a really good cake recipe, so if you're gonna try another one soon, I'd really suggest this:
http://www.saveur.com/article/Recipes/Black-Forest-Cherry-Torte
We replaced the kirschwasser with maraschino cherry liquid, and used maraschinos for the cherries on top as well (and had to use half raspberry preserves, half cherry jam for the jam part of this)...I would also suggest reducing the sugar in the icing, as its a very sweet cake.
But so good!
Anna says
Katherine, thanks for trying it! Sorry the tart cherries were so pricey, but it sounds like they were worth it in the end.
katherine says
I made this cake for our Christmas Eve dessert. It was outstanding! I did eventually find tart cherries... at $5 a can. Kind of pricey, but well worth it for a special cake. Thanks for sharing the recipe. Looking forward to making it again.
katherine says
Anna,
Do you think I can substitute pitted dark sweet Bing Cherries (in heavy syrup)?? It is the only kind I could find at the grocery store. Thanks.
Fat Fudge says
I once made a Black Forrest cake for my nephew from a Maida Heatter book. It was really boozy! The cake was soaked with kirsch, the filling had kirsch and so did the whip cream frosting. I made it the day before I was going to serve it and it was still pretty strong. I told my nephew that it was a good thing he just turned 21, or else he couldn't had eaten it!
Louise says
I hope you used Whip it in the whipped cream. It's the perfect use for the stuff.
Anna says
Todd says thanks for the birthday wishes!
Robbie, this is what a cake lifter looks like.
http://www.amazon.com/Wilton-2103-307-Cake-Lifter/dp/B001BOELLI
Clara Curtis says
That looks gorgeous! I definately want to try black forest cake; I feel like a fool for not trying that one yet!
Emily says
Happy birthday Todd! The cake looks amazing.
Robbie says
What does a cake lifter look like? Thanks! I'm making your German Chocolate Cake again tomorrow - it's been a huge success!
mags says
I've never had a black forest cake but you've got me wanting to try it. What an impressive birthday cake!
Pam Shank says
How beautiful your cake looks. I have never made one but I will after all the holiday madness.
HeartofGlass says
This was my favorite cake when I was 12 or so--the restaurant where I used to order it made it with chocolate mousse rather than whipped cream. So. good.
There are so many varieties with this cake, I look forward to further experimentation!
Sue says
And you say you're not crafty or a cake decorator!?Just look at that cake! It's beautiful!! Good to know you liked the taste of it too.
dawn says
ever since you tweeted about this I've been dying to see it. came out great, like everything you make.
I can only imagine your grocery bill, I bet it's like mine. LOL
Louise says
Anna, maybe you could overnight me a piece of cake. My birthday is tomorrow. 🙂
Cheryl says
Yum! I love blackforest cake, but have never attempted to make it - maybe I wont be so scared now:) Hope Todd had a great bday!
Chris Mower says
The name alone makes me want to eat this. Sounds delicious.
Joanne says
My friends got me a black forest cake when I got home from running my first marathon. I loved it! Thanks for this recipe, now I can make it myself.
Louise says
I can't do it today, but I'll send you Chef Tell's Black Forest Cake recipe. I haven't made it in awhile, and it's different than the one above, but it's excellent. It has a chocolate spongecake, kirschwasser, and all the right stuff. I'll also send the recipe from "Grandma Rose's Book of Sinfully Delicious Snacks, Nibbles, Noshes & Other Delights". It's also excellent. Chef Tell was an early TV chef who came from Germany. He ran into trouble, I believe with his Federal income tax or maybe drugs, and went to one of the islands for awhile.
Anna says
It may not be something you'd get in Germany, but this cake tasted great! I had some more today and it's even better on Day 2. Lisa, the extra chocolate might be good, but I don't think it needs anymore.
Jill, the skewer trick really works! If you don't have a skewer, a chopstick would probably work just as well.
Jill says
Thanks so much for the skewer tip! I'd never heard that one before.
Lisa Ernst says
This is a beautiful cake! I've never made, or eaten (as far as I remember) a black forest cake. I may have to try this sometime soon. I think I will make one alteration thought -- adding a layer of chocolate ganache to both the middle and top (before the whipped cream) to give me that chocolate intensity I always crave. LOL