Years ago someone in New York sent us a box of David’s Cookies. Back then David's Cookies were considered "gourmet" and unique because they had chocolate chunks instead of chips. They were rich, crumbly and came in a neat tin, but that's about all I can remember.
The company has changed over the years and I suppose the recipe has too, but there are lots of copycat recipes claiming to be similar to the original. One such David's Cookies recipe is from Maida Heatter's Cookies
No Baking Soda or Baking Powder
Maida's version of the David's Cookies recipe doesn't have baking soda or powder so the cookies have a texture similar to but slightly heavier than shortbread. A key point in the recipe is that the chocolate must be high quality chocolate and not chips. Maida stated that David used Lindt, which I also like to use in some recipes because it melts so nicely and set ups soft. Maida also says you can make the recipe as jumbo cookies, so I tried that too.
Both versions were very good, but I kind of preferred the giant cookies. If you try the recipe, let me know. I included some notes on measurements, grams, etc. As always, the best way to measure is with a scale.
Gluten-Free David's Cookies
Update: I still love this recipe, but I almost always make the large version and baking at 325 (see the note). Also, Bob's Gluten Free Flour works great! Just follow the directions as written, but weigh out 250 grams of GF flour. If the cookies spread more with your GF flour, push the edges inward with a spatula while the cookies are still hot.
Recipe
Not David's Cookies
Ingredients
- 8 oz good quality semisweet or dark chocolate (224 grams)
- 2 sticks unsalted butter, room temperature (224 grams)
- ½ teaspoon salt
- ½ teaspoon vanilla
- 1 cup light or dark brown sugar (200 grams)
- 1 large egg (50 grams_
- 2 cups sifted all-purpose flour (250 grams)
Instructions
- Chop the chocolate into small chunks and set aside.
- Beat the butter until creamy, then add the salt and vanilla. Scrape sides of bowl and add the sugar. Scrape side of bowl again and add the egg, then beat until blended.
- By hand, gradually stir in the flour until blended. Stir in the chocolate chunks.
- Using a rounded teaspoon, scoop about 40 (or slightly more) drops of dough onto foil lined plates or a foil lined baking sheet. Chill the dough thoroughly, then when it is cold and firm, shape the mounds of dough into neat balls.
- Preheat the oven to 400 degrees F (for the smaller cookies). Line a baking sheet with parchment paper (do not attempt to grease it as this makes the surface too slippery and the cookies will spread and burn). If you don’t have parchment, you can use a Silpat or plain foil.
- Arrange dough balls 2 ½ inches apart on a baking sheet and bake for around 7 minutes or until edges are brown and centers appear set. Remove from oven and let sit on the baking sheet until the cookies can safely be transferred to a wire rack. Let cool completely.
Notes
- In Maida's Heatter's Cookies, she says to bake these at 400 degrees F, but gives a variation for making large cookies that bake at 350. In my experience, the small cookies can be baked at 400 if you watch them closely, but 375 also works and the cookies will be less likely to burn. Ovens are probably more efficient these days.
- The large cookies are definitely better baked at 325
- Maida’s original recipe calls for 2 cups sifted all-purpose flour. 2 cups sifted could weigh anywhere between 8 or 9 oz. 8 ½ oz is a good in between. If you don't have a scale, just sift, measure and go with 2 cups sifted.
- The recipe calls for a cup of light or dark brown sugar. I made some cookies with light and some with dark and liked both. The cookies made with dark spread a little more but had a great flavor. The cookies made with light had a nicer shape.
- Giant Cookie Variation: Follow the directions but divide the dough into 10 big chunks and chill. Shape into neat mounts, then set three mounds on a parchment lined baking sheet. Press down to about ½ inch thickness and bake for 20 minutes or until done. Maida baked her giant cookies at 350, but I had better luck baking mine at 325 for about 20 minutes.
Anna says
This list makes sense because soy flour and special margarine blends seem to be in commercial cookie doughs. Soy flour helps with browning and the fat blend helps with taste and texture. Thanks for sharing.
Alex ossman says
Hi
David’s cookie used 12 ingredients
1- cake flour
2-sugar
3-brown sugar
4-butter blend
5- butter
6-eggs
7-soy flour
8- inert sugar
9-salt
10- baking soda
11-natural vanilla
12-dark chocolate chunk
Anna says
Riley, I'd use those chips in a different recipe. These cookies are better with excellent chocolate. What makes them special is their texture. The flavor is fine, but it needs the good chocolate for its flavor and meltiness. The oil seeps out into the dough as it bakes and imbues the cookie with a little more richness. With chips, you'll get none of that. I love chips, but recommend them in a different cookie recipe.
Riley says
what would happen if i used regular chocolate chips?
Jeff says
davids cookies used a fancier butter. and were thinner crunchier. those look way too puffy. 75% crunchy 25% chewy!
Anna says
Thanks for your comment, Tracy. Have a good day.
Tracy Boone says
I tried this recipe and this does not taste like David’s Cookies from the 80s
Anna says
Hi Jeff,
That makes total sense! They probably used something like Plugra or President brand butter -- something with a high butterfat content. They might have even used "dry butter" which is what French pastry chefs use.
Jeff says
Years ago I found the original Davids cookie recipe and had them made at our wedding. What I do know is that it used a higher end butter that is hard to find. Good luck finding the original recipe!
Gloria says
Wow, I'very been for 28 years wishing to go back to NY being one of the reasons the marvellous David's cookies but now I can relax as I'very found this wonderful recipe which seems to me even better than the originals I tried in 1988 GLoria, Madrid/Spain
Anna says
Hey There BB! I hope you are doing well. Thanks for the comment, and it's great to hear from you. Let me know what you think of the David's Cookies. They're different, for sure. I'm curious to hear what you think. Glad you liked the old Rice Krispies recipe.
Baking blonde says
wow, those look great. I was just looking for something to bake today. I just made your brownies with Rice Krispies and they were great!