I’ll take a good store bought ice cream sandwich any day. In fact, I like them so much I’ve made an entire ice cream cake with them. However, making homemade ice cream sandwiches is even more fun because you can experiment with different bases and fill them with whatever type of ice cream you feel like eating. In this case, that ice cream was homemade chocolate mint.
The base is a thin brownie that’s neither too crunchy nor too firm when frozen. I found the original recipe in the 2002 July/August issue of Cook’s Illustrated, but I changed the technique somewhat. They cut their brownie into rounds (and the ice cream, too) and they also use a 17×11 inch jelly-roll pan to bake the cookie base. Since I couldn’t find my 17×11 inch pan, I experimented and made the base by dividing it between two 9 inch square pans. I also tried spreading in a 9×13 inch pan. As expected, the 9×13 inch pan made too thick of a base, while dividing between the two 9 inch pans yielded a thinner crust that was easier to bite into. So if you don’t have the 17×11 inch pan, go with the two 9 inch pans. And of course there’s always the option of halving, in which case you’d want to use just one 9 inch square pan.
Update: I compared this recipe to the NYT recipe and still prefer this one because the brownies are a little less crumbly and greasy. I also changed up the ice cream a bit!
Homemade Ice Cream Sandwiches With Mint Ice Cream
Ingredients
- 1 cup unbleached all-purpose flour or weigh out exactly 5 oz/140 grams**
- 1/2 cup Dutch process or Hershey’s Extra Dark cocoa powder natural okay, too**
- 1/4 teaspoon salt
- 1/8 teaspoon baking soda
- 2 large eggs
- 2/3 cup granulated sugar
- 1/4 cup chocolate syrup
- 1/2 teaspoon vanilla extract
- 8 tablespoons unsalted butter melted
- 2 pints of your favorite ice cream.
Instructions
- Preheat oven to 350.
- Line an 11x17 inch jelly-roll pan or two 9 inch square pans with nonstick foil.
- In a medium size bowl, thoroughly mix together the flour, cocoa powder, salt and baking soda.
- In a large mixing bowl using a handheld electric mixer, beat the eggs and sugar for about a minute. Beat in the chocolate syrup, vanilla extract and butter until mixture turns light brown. With a heavy rubber scraper or a spoon, stir in the flour mixture until incorporated.
- Pour batter into lined pan and bake 10-12 minutes or until cakes seem firm and set. Remove from oven and let cool completely. Lift from pan and set cookie on a large cutting board.
- Cut the cookie lengthwise to make two long rectangles, then cut cross-wise to make 4 rectangles (this makes them easier to work with). Place one of the rectangles on a big sheet of plastic wrap and spoon ice cream evenly over the top. Cover with second rectangle and press down slightly. Wrap tightly in plastic. Repeat with second set of rectangles. Set on a baking sheet and put in the freezer overnight or until very firm.
- Using a large knife, trim the sides to give the sandwiches a clean edge. Cut each section into 4 rectangles.
Notes
Anna
Hi Katie,
I’m glad you liked them! Thanks for the tip on flattening the dough. Mine was definitely too thin to roll, but I suppose if you used a greased rolling pin you could gently roll it over it to flatten — I think that’s what you meant, right?
By the way, did you weigh your flour or just measure it? I always weigh mine. If you measured by volume, you could have used up to 5 1/2 or even 6 oz of flour which might have contributed to the thickness of the dough.
Katie
MADE IT: They were quite good, almost fudgy. But for a heads up, the “dough” was very very thick in my case. I would even recommend using a rolling pin greased with butter to get it nice and thin and flat, and using parchment paper instead of tin foil.
Amy @ What Jew Wanna Eat
Ice cream sandwiches are one of my favorite desserts ever! Besides mint chocolate chip ice cream. This combines them both- yum!
Holiday Baker Man
Perfect for the upcoming long weekend!
Rebecca
I might need to make these soon! They look just the thing for the heat wave we’re expecting.
Darlene
Carla Hall (on the Chew) gave a great suggestion for filling homemade ice cream sandwiches. To prevent ice crystals from forming when you let store-bought ice cream soften and then re-harden, she cuts down the sides of a rectangular ice cream container, peels it away, and then slices the still frozen hard ice cream. I think she then used a biscuit/cookie cutter to cut the ice cream and brownies into round shapes, assembled, and rolled the edges in assorted treats (mini chocolate chips, M&Ms, etc).
Gloria
These look delicious. I have a batch of your vanilla ice cream in the freezer now. Wish I would have done my homework better and read your post on how to make melt-in-your-mouth chocolate chunks for ice cream. I ended up with tasteless, hard chunks. I think I’m going to pick them out and try your oil method!!! Hate to ruin a batch of delicious ice cream!!!