My collection of Levain Copycat recipes is out of control, which is funny because I actually prefer thin and crisp chocolate chip cookies or even tiny mini chocolate chip cookies. But my friends back in Texas and Chicago go crazy for big fat cookies, so I’ve continued to play with this small batch Levain Copycat recipe over the years.
The pictures below are from my first attempts to make similar cookies without having ever tried a cookie from their bakery.
Eventually my friend Taneka took me to the Upper West Side where we bought the real thing, which were (are) way better and which gave me an idea of how the cookies should be – thick, oozing with chocolate and slightly under-baked.
From that point I made small batch Levain copycats — some with baking soda and powder, others with just soda, all with different types and ratios of flour. At one point I thought European style butter might be key because my cookies made with Plugra were coming out thicker and tastier, but I’ve since given up that idea because not all European style butter work the same plus I don’t think an American bakery could make a profit using European style butter in cookies. So now I just use Land o’ Lakes and whatever flours I feel like playing with.
Experimenting is always fun, and if you are new to it you may want to start with a small batch recipe. This is one I came up with early on. It calls for all baking soda, no powder and lots of walnuts. It must be refrigerated and you pretty much have to use the walnuts to get the texture and shape right.
In addition to the small batch version, I’ve added a “regular size” batch. I’ve been making these for years with very good results.
If you don’t like walnuts or have tried this version and aren’t happy with it, here’s another big fat cookie recipe people seem to like. Roasting a small portion of the flour makes them tall and thick. Unlike the one on this page, the other works well without the walnuts.
SUPER Small Batch Levain Copy Cats
4 tablespoons unsalted cold butter, cut into chunks (58 grams)
2 tablespoons granulated sugar (25 grams)
3 tablespoons packed brown sugar (36 grams)
2 tablespoons lightly beaten egg (25 grams)**
1/4 teaspoon vanilla
83 grams all-purpose flour (or try your own variations using bread & AP etc.)
1/4 teaspoon salt (scant)
1/4 scant teaspoon baking soda (just a little under 1/4)******
1/2 teaspoon cornstarch (optional)
Large handful chocolate chips (semisweet)
Large handful whole toasted walnuts
In a mixing bowl, using an electric mixer, beat cold butter and both sugars just until they come together. Don’t overbeat. Add the cold egg and vanilla and beat just until mixed. Don’t keep beating until smooth – you want it to be roughly creamed.
Stir together flour, salt, baking soda and cornstarch. When thoroughly mixed, add to creamed mixture and stir. The dough should seem kind of dry at this point.
Before the flour is fully mixed in, add the walnuts and chocolate chips and continue mixing (may need to use hands) allowing some of the walnuts to break.
Divide dough into 2 big balls or make 1 big ball (6 oz) and a “mini” ball (3 oz). Stack them in the bowl, then cover and chill the dough for an hour or so (or overnight if possible).
When ready to bake, bake on a parchment lined cookie sheet in a 350 degree oven for 21 minutes. Let sit on cookie sheet for about 10 minutes to cool, them remove.
Makes 2 — Alternatively, you can make 3 cookies. Bake time will be slightly shorter. If baking with convection, bake at 350 for about 18 minutes. Also, if for some reason your cookies spread too much, carefully push the edges inward before the cookies are done baking.
Note on Flour: I’m always experimenting with flours, but I’ve found that bleached all-purpose makes the cookies a little fatter and softer. For the small batch version you would use 83 grams bleached AP flour. Also, a mixture of eggs and yolk gives you taller, thicker cookies than beaten egg alone. To use egg and yolk in a small batch, crack and egg and one yolk into a small cup and mix with a fork until thoroughly blended. Weigh out 17 grams and add to the small batch recipe.
Note on Baking Soda & Powder — If you are not using nuts, you’ll need to incorporate some baking powder. To make these without walnuts, use only 1/8 teaspoon of baking soda and 1/4 teaspoon of baking powder.
Not So Small Batch Levain Copycats
- 1 cup cake flour 114 grams (or just use AP)
- 1 3/4 cup bread flour 220 grams (or just use equivalent AP)
- 1-2 teaspoon cornstarch not critical, but helps with thickness
- 3/4 teaspoon baking soda
- 1 teaspoon salt
- 1 cup unsalted Land o Lakes butter 230 grams, cold and cut into small chunks
- 3/4 cup lightly packed light brown sugar 145 grams
- 1/2 cup granulated cane sugar 100 grams
- 2 large eggs or use 1 extra large egg and 1 egg yolk
- 1/2 teaspoon vanilla extract
- 1 cup toasted and chopped walnuts see note if you omit
- 1 cup best quality semisweet chocolate chips you can use more or less
- This dough must be chilled thoroughly for best results, so no need to preheat the oven until ready to bake.
- Mix together the flours, cornstarch, salt and baking soda and set aside. It's always nice to get that part out of the way, plus it gives you time to properly measure and weigh your flour.
- In a large mixing bowl, beat the butter until it is creamy. Add both sugars and beat until blended, then reduce speed and add the eggs, one at a time, and vanilla. Be sure to scrape the sides of the bowl.
- Now add the flour mixture gradually, stirring or beating on low until it is fully blended, then stir in the walnuts and chips.
- Turn dough out onto a clean surface and bunch it up into a big ball. Divide into six equal lumps (or make six 6 oz cookies). Arrange on a tray or two large plates, cover, then chill overnight.
- When ready to bake, preheat the oven to 375. Bake 3 at a time for about 18 minutes. Allow them to sit and thoroughly cool. They'll seem slightly doughy in the center, but once they cool and set they taste good. Alternatively, you can bake at 400 for 10 minutes, then reduce heat and bake at 350 for another 8 to 10 minutes. Starting at 400 usually results in taller cookies.