(The Latest) New York Times Chocolate Chip Cookies

Update: I’ve been making these a lot lately for bake sales. Their size and shape make them really impressive, but they don’t stay fresh very long so if you make them ahead of time, keep them in the freezer. The best bet is to make the dough ahead of time and bake the cookies a few hours before the sale.

Chalk one up for delayed gratification, because these cookies are delicious. Chilling them overnight was definitely worth it. Then again, we knew that, right? This was just another excuse to make chocolate chip cookies.

As predicted, they are very good. I measured all the ingredients by weight and ended up with medium-thick, chocolate packed cookies with chewy centers and crispy edges. The only thing I couldn’t use was (sigh) Valrhona. However, a combo of Ghirardelli bittersweet chips and Lindt 70% chunks worked quite nicely.

Here’s a link to the original New York Times Chocolate Chip Cookie recipe, and below is my adapted version. I like to shape the dough ahead of time and bake the cookies as needed.

The cookie in this photo doesn’t have any fancy salt on it. I opted to leave it off a few of the cookies and test whether I liked salted vs. unsalted. I liked them both equally, but the unsalted cookie was prettier. What I can’t figure out is why mine looks so different from the picture. I am thinking it has to do with either 1) the size of the chocolate chunks I used and/or 2) the insulated cookie sheet.

New York Times Chocolate Chip Cookie

(The Latest) New York Times Chocolate Chip Cookies
 
Prep time
Cook time
Total time
 
Giant chocolate chip or chocolate chunk cookies. These are perfect for wrapping individually and giving as gifts.
Author:
Recipe type: Dessert
Cuisine: American
Serves: 18
Ingredients
  • 2 cups minus 2 tablespoons (8 1/2 ounces) cake flour
  • 1 2/3 cups (8 1/2 ounces) bread flour
  • 1 1/4 teaspoons baking soda
  • 1 1/2 teaspoons baking powder
  • 1 1/2 teaspoons coarse salt
  • 2 1/2 sticks (1 1/4 cups) unsalted butter
  • 1 1/4 cups (10 ounces) light brown sugar
  • 1 cup plus 2 tablespoons (8 ounces) granulated sugar
  • 2 large eggs
  • 2 teaspoons natural vanilla extract
  • 3 cups of the best chocolate chips you can find
  • Sea salt -- good, but I omit it half the time and the cookie are still great.
Instructions
  1. Thoroughly mix the flours, baking soda, baking powder and salt into a bowl. Set aside.
  2. Using a mixer fitted with paddle attachment (a handheld mixer is fine), cream butter and sugars together until very light, about 5 minutes. Add eggs, one at a time, mixing well after each addition. Stir in the vanilla. By hand, stir in the flour mixture. When flour is incorporated, stir in the chocolate. At this point, I like to shape the cookies and chill the shaped balls.
  3. Line a baking sheet with parchment paper and scoop out about 18 equal size balls. Chill until the dough is firm and the balls don't stick together, then put in a bag and chill overnight.
  4. When ready to bake, preheat oven to 350 degrees and bring dough to room temperature.
  5. Line a baking sheet with parchment paper or a nonstick baking mat and arrange about 6 dough balls per sheet. Press the tops down slightly and sprinkle tops with sea salt if desired.
  6. Bake for 18 to 20 minutes. Let cool on the baking sheet for 5 to 10 minutes and then transfer to a cooling rack to finish cooling.
  7. I like to transfer them to the refrigerator to quick cool and prefer the chocolate set rather than warm and melty.
Notes
Jacques Torres makes these with Valrhona fèves, oval-shaped chocolate pieces. You can sometimes find them at Whole Foods. I make them with whatever good chocolate I can get my hands on. If I'm using chips, I like to use the Ghirardelli 60% bittersweet chips.

 

Related posts:

Comments

  1. says

    I’m so glad you tried these out so soon and shared them with us! They are definitely on my agenda for the weekend. I can’t wait to try them. Do they rank up there with some of your other chocolate chip recipes, like Jacques Torres?

  2. Marie says

    I’m so excited you made these and posted the link as well. I was all set to order some chocolate discs from Jacques Torres but they wanted $41.00 for shipping! I laughed for a long time over that. Maybe I’ll wait till it’s cooler where I live to order some. I’ll get some Valrhona from Trader Joe’s in the meantime.

    I made both your latest oatmeal cookie and the peanut butter cookies from the week before last and they were great. They stayed fresh for almost a week. I’m looking forward to trying these, especially since I have a huge bag of bread flour left over from my Levain cookies.

  3. says

    These look fabulous! Better than Levain and much more chocolatey. Can’t wait to try them. I’d be interested, too, in where you would rank these cookies on your favorites scale.I don’t know many people who have tried as many variations of chocolate chip cookies as you.:-)

  4. says

    I am going to try those next week! They look and sound wonderful.
    I typically freeze my dough in preshaped balls for future baking (I don’t need 3 doz cookies at a time), I wonder if freezing and chilling have similar effects on the dough? HMMM,

    Either way I love trying new recipes and will be chilling the dough overnight and baking a few before freezing the rest of the dough balls! Can’t wait!!

  5. says

    I think yours look great, but I think I like a thicker cookie. I just baked off a 20 hour chilled dough cookie. It looks pretty much identical to the one I posted last night. I haven’t tasted it yet.
    Yours also look more chocolatey than mine. When I make these again, I’m going to put in more chocolate, although I halved the recipe this time and put in the right amount of chocolate.
    Did you measure out 3 1/2 oz. dough for yours, like the recipe suggests? I did and these cookies are huge! Can’t believe it’s only about half the amount they use for the Levains. Obviously just a different cookie. I am loving this one though.

  6. Anonymous says

    I am not a member of the NY Times – does anyone have a link to a typed out recipe?

  7. Rachel B. says

    For those who want to make cookies with a less exhorbitant “chocolate disk” (about 1″ across), I highly recommend the Merckens Bittersweet Buttons that you can order through King Arthur Flour for about $6/lb. This isn’t the time of year to do it most places, but when the weather permits, they’re one of my favorite baking chocolates!

    I bet you could also make your own melty chunks, either by melting dark chocolate–not chocolate chips, with their extra stabilizing ingredients!–and piping it into dots. Or, less labor intensive, just spreading melted chocolate into a 1/4″ layer on parchment on a cookie sheet and cutting it into chunks after it firms up.

  8. says

    Ooo I was just reading about this cookie yesterday and I’m impressed you’ve already made it! Good to know it turns out as promised. Your cookie looks delicious (and I think very similar to the one posted with the article).

  9. Michelle says

    I think you’ve convinced me to give this one a try Anna. I wasn’t going to try any more chocolate chip cookies since I love the JT ones you posted before. Do you like these better?

  10. Katy says

    I am about to whip up the dough so I can bake these this weekend. Anna, they will be thicker than original JT because there’s less egg and more baking powder (reduces spread). And you used thicker chips. I am using Guittard 61% wafers.(available at our market here in SF because they’re local and make all the chocolate for See’s Candies) And I think they need 3 tsp of vanilla because of the volume of dough and I happen to love vanilla. FYI, the JTs sold at the store in NY are fairly flat and measure about 5-6″ in diameter. I will report back after they’re baked but I am excited to try yet another CCC and see how they compare to the JT original (the ones he made on Martha)

  11. says

    I will probably try this next week, I hope to find a similar chocolate over the weekend when I go shopping.
    I’m glad you tried them Anna, they look very good!

  12. floretbroccoli says

    I am only a dabbler in cookies and wondered why 8.5 oz. of bread flour and 8.5 oz. of cake flour. Wouldn’t 17 oz. of AP give you pretty much the same protein content?

  13. says

    Ashley, take a look at Katrina’s. Hers looks more like the JT cookies. But I’m not complaining. I like mine a lot.

    Michelle, I think these are more convenient. I usually have cake and bread flour in the house, but not pastry flour. A lot of people can’t even find pastry flour.

    Katy, let’s discuss this via email when you make the cookies. I am curious to hear how the Guittard wafers work. Sometimes when I use them, they melt a little too much. Maybe we are using different Guittard products.

    Rita, I am sure your cookies will be fabulous as always ;).

    Broccoli Floret!

    You must be an advanced dabbler.

    I was wondering the same thing about using AP because I read somewhere that the protein content of all purpose was similar to what you’d get if you mixed bread flour and cake or pastry flour.

    Maybe the cake flour/bread flour combo is there because the bread flour lends some extra gluten while the cake flour incorporates a softer wheat. Or maybe the cake flour is there because its higher startch content makes the edges crispier.

    There’s more to flour than just protein content, so it must be other characteristics of the two flours, combined, that make the cookie what it is.

  14. says

    Hooray Anna! I knew I could count on you to give us the skinny on the lastest cookie craze. I’m definitely going to try them the next time I get a craving that I can dely for 24 hours.:)

  15. Heidi says

    I wanted to add that I bought some Guittard bittersweet chocolate discs and they were not too expensive. I can’t remember for the life of me where I bought them however – if it was a Central Market kind of place, the local grocery, or Sur la Table…

    Ok, I lied, on the Guittard website it says a 1 lb box is $12. I probably bought it at Sur la Table when I had my 20% off.

  16. Yet Another Anna says

    Hi Anna!

    I knew you’d give these a try! I baked mine just this morning, but made mine smaller, used smaller (and fewer) chips, and left off the salt on the tops.

    Truly wonderful cookie dough.

    I’m going to experiment and freeze some of the leftover dough, just to see how well they respond.

    I really love freshly baked cookies, but the slice and bake stuff at the grocery store has lost its’ appeal. :) This recipe should make a nice substitute, if the dough freezes well. :)

  17. Katy says

    Another tip from Sherry Yard. She slices and bakes her cc cookies from a thick log in order to get lots of exposed chocolate for the melty factor.

  18. says

    Anna,

    I don’t know what you’re talking about! Your cookies are gorgeous. I didn’t bake the cookies in the NYT’s photos, but when I made them to test/research them for the article, I used a half sheet pan made of aluminum with a Silpat on top. I formed the dough into pretty much round balls and turned all the feves and discs horizontal, parallel to the baking sheet. They melted better that way. That’s how I got that “Sharpei” look.

    Happy baking,

    David Leite

  19. says

    Sue, I’m behind on my blogs today. I will take a look at that tomorrow. Can’t wait to hear KA’s take.

    Erin, I suspect that by now you have the dough in the refrigerator ;).

    Heidi, let me know how the Guittard discs work out. I once bought some fancy Guittard discs, but it turned out they were for melting and dipping. The chips melted too much during the baking process. I do like their normal semi-sweet chips and the now-discontinued super chips. I’m sure the discs you bought will be fine. I just bought the wrong type.

    Katy, thanks for reminding me. I need to pull out my Sherry Yard book.

    David, thanks for stopping by! Also, thanks for the new recipe. It will save a lot of people the hassle of hunting down pastry flour used in the old version.

    I baked my cookie on an Air Bake Ultra cookie sheet and think that might have had something to do with the thickness. I’m going to try baking the next round on a regular cookie sheet and see if they come out a bit flatter. Not that it’s a big deal. I think I will also be more mindful in forming the cookies and arranging the feves and discs.

  20. says

    To me, your cookies have far more appeal than the ones pictured in the NY Times article. Although I’ve never tasted a Levain chocolate chip cookie, the photos I’ve seen of them leave me drooling. I’ve experimented right along with your quest for the recipe and gained 5 pounds in the process. Seems silly to praise you for my weight gain, but I really enjoy your blog.

  21. Heidi says

    I’m completely intimidated by the ingredients by weight not volume, and the amount of chocolate called for 1 1/4 lbs for 6 cookies!?! I don’t even LIKE ccc cookies that much – I have to have nuts and stuff in them. These will wait until the hubby asks for them.

  22. Priscilla says

    Thanks for posting this great recipe. I made the cookie over the weekend and substituted what I had, which was 3 1/2 cups of all-purpose flour for the 2 special flours and ordinary semisweet chocolate chips. I baked them after 24 hours using the 3 1/2 ounces on a heavy aluminum sheet with no liner. They were excellent, with a crisp edge and chewy middle. They looked similar to the NYT picture, but with a few less wrinkles, although still beautifully crackled. I also baked some small ones for a party but I wanted finger food, so I used about 1 tablespoon of dough for each and baked at 375. I only chilled these for 12 hours. These small cookies were crispy and tender, and if I baked for only 8 minutes they stayed a little chewy in the center. Next time I might try two ouncers and see what happens.

  23. says

    Hi Priscilla,

    Thanks so much for testing with 100% all purpose flour. Some day I’d like to do a side-by-side taste test with the bread/cake flour cookies vs. 100% AP.

  24. floretbroccoli says

    I put the batter together Tuesday morning. (AP flour, Guittard 70% wafers.)

    I’ll be baking them tonight (36 hours) and will report back.

    In a preliminary test last night, I found the refrigerated dough nearly impossible to scoop. My solution was to leave the bowl out for an hour, then scoop. I then refrigerated the dough balls. This will certainly make tonight’s task easier.

    Anybody have any thoughts on scooping dough after the butter has re-chilled?

  25. floretbroccoli says

    Reporting back.

    While probably not the best chocolate chip cookies I’ve ever tasted, they are certainly the best ones I’ve ever made. (I’ve never been a great chocolate-chip cookie baker.)

    I baked off 8 last night. My guests ate some of the remaining batter, but I plan on shaping what’s left and freezing it, so I can bake a few more on Saturday.

    I’m going to try to pick up a cookie or two at Jacques Torres on Friday, so I’ll be able to compare.

  26. says

    I made this dough up on Friday and baked them last night. I did them exactly to the recipe, including the size of the cookies. I think the technique is great – the texture of these cookies was perfect – crispy on the outside, chewy on the inside. But both my boyfriend and I felt like the flavor of the cookie was not very exciting. Yeah, the chocolate was good (isn’t it always), but the cookie itself was nothing to write home about. Good, yes. Exceptional – no. I’ve got another chocolate chip cookie recipe that’s been my standard, so I’m going to try that one using the extended chill technique and see how it does! Thanks for alerting us to this great article.

  27. Karen says

    I also tried these, really sticking to the recipe using bread and cake flours and weighing everything. I used chocolate disks from El Rey, I have never used those before. They were 6.99 a pound. I also used Plugra butter. I baked half the dough after 33 hours and the rest after about 80 hours. These were good, especially when warm, but I don’t know what all the fuss is about!

  28. Beth says

    I’ve made these twice now, using AP flour both times, but the first time I goofed and only used 1 1/4 teaspoon baking powder. I actually think they were better that way – much chewier and more… supple, for lack of a better word. I’ll try making them again in a few weeks to see if I can replicate the original results, or if there was another factor that caused the difference.

  29. Shannon says

    I know this is an old post, but I just wanted to comment that this is now referred to as “The Favorite Chocolate Chip Cookie” recipe at my house. I’ve made it several times, and have continued trying other recipes as well, but nothing else has beat this recipe yet. The only slight change I make is to use regular chocolate chips instead of discs and they are still amazing!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Rate This Recipe: