All-Time Favorites from Cookie Madness is a category with personal favorites. These recipes are great tasting, relatively fun to make, and usually get requested by friends. I'm trying to keep this category updated, but sometimes I forget to add things. If you have a recipe you believe belongs in the category, please let me know!
This category has a lot of great recipes, but a few that come to mind right now as being very, very good are the Divorce Carrot Cake from Reddit. It's the best carrot cake I've ever tasted. The Chicago Public School Butter Cookies recipe is popular with readers, as is the Self-Rising Flour Banana Bread. The Atlantic Beach Pie made with a Ritz crust is awesome, and I also love the Malted Milk Chocolate Chunk Cookies which is odd because I usually prefer dark or semisweet in cookies. There's something about the milk with the malt.