Originally from Joanne Chang, this recipe is adapted from one in The Atlantic, where Joanne Chang gives tips on how to make the Flour Bakery Chocolate Chip Cookies. Since posting this adapted version of the recipe I have made the cookies many, many times and they're always good. They have a great texture with crispy edges, soft centers and brown sugar flavor. They’re up there with the greatest of all times chocolate chip cookies.
For best results, use the weights rather than volume. Also, chill the dough! You can bake a couple of cookies right away, but the cookies are so much better made with dough that's been chilled overnight.
UPDATE: Be careful what type of chocolate you use for Joanne Chang's Chocolate Chip Cookies. I love Lindt, but it melts fast and can cause these cookies to spread. Some other smooth, high quality, melting chocolates will also give you more spread.
More Joanne Chang Recipes
Since posting Joanne Chang's Chocolate Chip Cookies recipe, she's shared another. Here's a link to a thin and crunchy version. She also has a great blueberry muffin recipe.
Recipe
Joanne Chang's Chocolate Chip Cookies (Or Chocolate Chunk!)
Ingredients
- 175 grams all-purpose flour, volume can be (1 ¼ to 1 ⅓ cups)
- 160 grams bread flour (1 cup plus 2 tablespoons)
- 1 teaspoon baking soda
- ½ teaspoon salt
- 230 grams unsalted butter, softened (1 cup)
- 150 grams granulated sugar (¾ cup)
- 165 grams packed brown sugar (I sometimes use 150) (¾ cup) but VERY tightly packed**
- 2 large eggs
- ¾ teaspoon vanilla
- 255 grams chopped bittersweet chocolate or quality chocolate chips
- 70 grams chopped milk chocolate
Instructions
- Whisk the dry ingredients (flour through salt) together in a medium size bowl. Set aside.
- In a large mixing bowl, beat butter and sugars together until very light and fluffy, scraping down the side of the bowl as needed. Beat in the eggs, one at a time, mixing until well combined after each. Mix in vanilla.
- Toss bittersweet and milk chocolates into the dry ingredients - mix to coat. Add dry ingredients to mixing bowl and mix until completely combined. Cover and place cookie dough into the refrigerator to chill for 24 hours.
- When ready to bake, preheat oven to 350 degrees.
- Scoop out about ¼ cup worth of dough per cookie and roll each into a ball - place onto parchment lined baking sheets two to three inches apart, then flatten each slightly.
- Bake one sheet at a time until the cookies are golden brown around the edges, yet the center is still slightly soft, about 14 to 17 minutes. Remove and place baking sheets onto a wire rack and allow cookies to cool (still on the baking sheet) for 5 to 10 minutes. Transfer cookies to the rack and allow to cool completely.
Anna says
I like this one too. It's a solid, professional style version of the Toll House recipe and you can make all kinds of little changes to it. It's due for some new photos, so I should make a batch today. Thanks Mary Jo.
Mary Jo says
I learned about Joanne's baking techniques from the "Master Class" series. The first lesson involved making this cookie, which became my favorite chocolate chip recipe ever!
Anna says
Amanda, thanks for tips! Totally agree about the salt.
Amanda Hermann says
I love this recipe! I watched Joanne Chang's Master Class and by far has changed how I bake cookies. Time is key! Making sure your butter/sugar is as fluffy as possible and not rushing this process. I did not have bread flour on hand this time around and also added 1 tsp of vanilla instead of 3/4 and still had great results. I do also like to add a bit more salt than 1/2 tsp. that's just a personal taste that balances the sweet.
Sue says
Ha! I didn't remember making these but from the comment above I see I did. I love the texture of these cookies. Having just made them I've decided they will be the house chocolate chip cookie. Five stars for sure.
Sue says
I made the version of these that you linked to from the Boston Globe in a list of five favorite chocolate chip cookies. The recipe didn't have vanilla listed in the ingredients list but did in the instructions. I used 1.5 tsp. I love this recipe! I made mine with a regular cookie scoop instead of making them big and baked them for 13 minutes. The texture is perfect.
Anna says
Linda, I think an extra 1/4 cup of flour would have made yours a little thicker. There was a small discrepancy in that article. It had a little more flour than what is listed in the book. Based on the fact mine were really good using the extra 1/4 cup of flour, I'd stick with that. The article has been (mostly) removed, so I linked to Joe.
About the other questions, it sounds like you answered them all yourself! I'll email you another recipe to try.
Linda says
Whoops, should also have mentioned that both the bread and regular flours I used were unbleached.
Linda says
Anna, I'm on my annual quest for the best cc cookie for holiday gifts - meaning they have to be somewhat sturdy, taste great, and keep as well as possible as they are traveling. I tried this recipe, and like others, my cookies were fairly flat - they look nothing like yours. I weigh my ingredients, so that shouldn't be the issue. Here are the changes I made - I used half shortening (I know, I know, but it does make them keep better) which if anything, should have made them puffier rather than thinner; and I added 1 1/2 t. vanilla. The link to the original article only shows part of the recipe, but I found the recipe on Lisa's Sweet as Sugar blog, and other than the changes she notes, I'm assuming it's the original recipe. They do taste great, and I'm going to try them again. As you noted, there might be differences with bread flours, and I'm also wondering if by beating the fats and sugars until fluffy is incorporating so much air that the cookies collapse at a certain point. I'm also wondering if different milk chocolates may make a difference. I used Hershey's bars. Any thoughts or suggestions? Thanks!
Anna says
That's subjective, but I have found that Scharffen Berger works really well in cookies. Smoother chocolates like Lindt (which I love) sometimes melt too fast and make certain cookies spread more. Valrhona and Callebaut are also really good.
Jackie says
Hi Anna
You suggest not to use high quality chocolate in this recipe. What brand of chocolate do you suggest using in this recipe.
Anna says
I think the problem might be with the bread flour. Certain brands have different weights and I think humidity affect flour volume as well. To be accurate, it's best to weigh the flour -- especially when you're using flour that's not all purpose. Since this is just the Toll House recipe with a couple of changes (flour, size, chocolate) the cookies shouldn't be flat.
The other culprit could be the type of chocolate. If you are using a high cocoa fat chocolate the chocolate might be melting quickly into the dough and causing spread. I've had this happen a lot of times.
Lissa says
Ack! Mine came out flat too. I chilled the dough over night and tested my baking soda, so those weren't the culprits. I used air-bake cookie sheets and used my convection function. Could either of those be the problem? I also did not weigh the flour, so I'll definitely do that next time. They tasted really good, so I will try again!
Anna says
Heidi, that's too bad! I saw that Food Librarian made them and hers were flat too, but not pancake flat and she did enjoy them. Why did you think the dough seemed low on flour? I'm just curious because that's the same ratio as the Toll House recipe.
I don't own the book yet but I plan on buying it :). Her recipes have always worked perfectly for me. I especially like some of her muffins.
Heidi says
Hi Anna,
I was so excited to try these CCC. Yours look awesome. Mine were not so impressive. They came out as flat as pancakes. I thought the dough seemed a little low on flour but I figured that thoroughly chilling the dough would keep them from spreading too much. Nope. They were FLAT. They didn't taste bad but they weren't spectacular either. But that's ok. I've tried a million recipes and I'm always on the lookout for another one to try. Thanks for telling us about it. I DO want to purchase her baking book she has available. There are several recipes in it that look fabulous. Do you own it and how do you like it if you do?
Heidi
Eridqua says
Hi All, I made these cookies this week and they were pretty good but not as good as the NYT recipe. These are very similar in taste to Toll House cookies since Joanne Chang based her recipe on that. I felt that they came out a bit too sweet and were definitely soft but not chewy. I did like the combo of different chocolates. The correct amount for the vanilla is 1/2 teaspoon. Joanne posted this same recipe as "Chocolate Chunk Cookies" once and it listed vanilla as 1/2 t. Hope that helps!
Louise says
It seems like a couple of commentors made these cc cookies. How are they in a couple of days? Or even just the next day?
Denise says
How much vanilla did you use? It is not listed in ingredients, but rather down in the instructions. Just curious. Thanks!
Anna says
Sounds like they were a little low on flour. Did you weigh or use volume measurements? I weighed the flour. Chilling the dough should help a little bit.
marsha says
for the recipe, click on chocolate chip cookie recipe in the description.
Lori @ RecipeGirl says
I'm always curious to try new chocolate chip cookie recipes. I made one the other day using almond flour (no actual flour at all) that was interesting. Bread flour for cookies is a new one- will have to try!
BakerMan says
I love a Great Chocolate Chip Cookie!
Amanda says
I just made these and they taste amazing. The combination of the milk and semi-sweet chocolate is delicious. But mine are not puffy and beautiful like yours Anna. They came out flat. Maybe because I didn't chill the dough...I baked half and have the other half sitting in the fridge until tomorrow. I just couldn't wait 🙂 Maybe the next batch will be better.
Mackenzie@The Caramel Cookie says
I love using bread flour for chocolate chip cookies!
Sue says
Oh my! These sound fantastic!! Looking forward to trying them!
stephanie says
Have the dough chilling in the fridge. Any comparisons to this cookie recipe & the NYtimes cookie recipe. I made that one a few months ago. Curious to see how this one is.
TxPepper says
Anna loves her readers.
🙂
Pepper
Anna says
Linda, a few pastry chefs like leaving the vanilla out of cookies. I usually add some anyway. For this batch I used 1 teaspon. It's optional, but I like vanilla.
Anna says
Gloria, these tasted salty enough to me, but I forgot to mention I used salted butter. Glad the microwave tip works for you! All microwaves are different. Here in my new house, I have to use 50% power to toast nuts. It works, but you have to find the right settings.
Gloria says
CCC cookies are my favorite, but I'm so picky about them...usually they are too sweet for me and lack depth of flavor. I'm surprised she uses unsalted butter and only 1/2 teaspoon salt with all that sugar. Toll house calls for salted butter and 1 teaspoon salt and they don't seem "salty" to me. Go figure! Must be my over 50 year old taste buds!
On a sort of related note: Thanks for the time-saving tip about microwave-toasting a small batch of nuts. I had no idea that would work and it did!!!!! And, I have no idea which one of your posts I saw it on!!!
Jessica says
These look amazing! I've always wondered what the bread flour does to a chocolate chip cookie, and now I know. I especially love the giant gob of chocolate right in the middle of the second cookie in your picture :).
My favorite cookie recipe is the New York Times Cookie (http://www.nytimes.com/2008/07/09/dining/091crex.html), which contains bread AND cake flour, so I'll be sure to make this one and compare!
Linda says
I see in the comments on the recipe on The Atlantic website that the instructions note mixing in vanilla, but vanilla isn't listed in the ingredients. That comment wasn't answered, so, Anna, how much vanilla did you add?
natalie (the sweets life) says
ooh I love Joanne Chang! I can't wait to try these!
Christine says
These sound amazing! I may need to make these for the hubby as his Valentine's Day gift.
Katrina says
You beat me. I knew you'd make these after you last post and Louise suggested you make them. I went then and printed off the recipe. Hadn't gotten to them yet. But with your good seal of approval, I will make them soon for sure. They look great.
And we all know I already keep bread flour on hand for my current fave--NYT.
Hope you're having fun.
Louise says
Ginny, in the third paragraph above, Anna points to the recipe at http://www.theatlantic.com/food/archive/10/11/recipe-flour-bakery-cafe-chocolate-chip-cookies/66155/
Shannon in Canada says
ok, so I have never used bread flour for cookies. I think its probably time I gave it a try since I have read so much about it, but what exactly is it that the bread flour does for the cookies? I am assuming its a texture thing?
Helena says
I have so many chocolate chip cookie recipes with bread flour in my stash, but havn't tried any of them yet. I think I really need to give them a try!
vanillasugar says
i need to keep bread flour in the cupboard too.
stephanie says
Its my baking day: pumpkin muffins & scones. Now I have to try the chocolate spice muffins & a NEW CCC recipe. Thank you! Off to the kitchen.........
Ginny says
So where is the recipe already?
Amanda says
It must have been a CCC weekend or something, this is the third CCC recipe post I've seen today! 🙂 They look amazing as usual!
Fallon says
The bread flour really makes them a hefty cookie. Must bookmark for future CC cookie baking. I can see why this is a popular cookie.
Amy @ What Jew Wanna Eat says
Those look awesome! I am always looking for new CCC (I am stealing Lisa's acronym) recipes. It's a classic for a reason! I may add some vanilla to mine, though, as I just love that flavor.
Lisa Ernst says
The cookies look beautiful, and I love the generous amount of chips called for in the recipe. I'm bookmarking this one for the next time I want to bake some special CCC's. (So far my two favorite recipes are the NY Times recipe and your Ultimate Stand Mixer CCC recipe.)
Amanda says
These look like my favorite kind of chocolate chip cookie. I have been baking your Jumbo 3 Chip cookies for weeks now and everyone tells me they are the best chocolate chip cookies ever. Looks like I'll have to buy some bread flour!