I love trying new white cake recipes, but this one isn't exactly new. In fact, it's so old it's often referred to as"silver cake" which is the name given to white cakes back when cakes made with yolks were called gold cakes. So gold cakes had yolks, silver cakes had whites. From what I've read, the terms yellow cake and white cake came later, when butter became a more prominent cake ingredient. But this isn't about the history of cake, it's about the Betty Crocker Silver White Cake.
White Cake With Shortening
This is a big fluffy true white cake made with shortening and egg whites. The recipe calls for both vanilla and almond extract. Vanilla is the main flavor, but the almond extract adds "that little something". It doesn't necessarily make it taste almond-y. Frosting choices are many, but ignore the pink frosting in the photo. It's a strawberry frosting made with freeze dried strawberries, and I was not impressed. I still think the best strawberry frostings are the ones with cream cheese, fresh strawberry puree and maybe a little jam, but that's a whole 'nother story.
Cake Flour
For Betty Crocker Silver White Cake, I think it's important to use cake flour. Having made the cake with and without it, it's much more like a bakery cake when made with cake flour. Also, cake flour has less gluten so you can beat the batter longer without toughening up gluten-strands. It matters in this recipe because egg whites are beaten in at the end and not folded in separately. So when using cake flour you can worry less about beating the batter and toughening up the cake.
Shortening vs. Butter
As for the shortening vs. butter, shortening gives you a whiter, fluffier cake. You don't get the butter flavor, but you still get the flavor that some people associate with birthday cakes. I'm not sure how much the butter flavor is actually missed here given the other flavors, but I totally understand not wanting to use shortening and will post a butter version soon. But I loved how this one works with Crisco, and I say "Crisco" because I tried it with another brand (starts with Wal and ends with Mart) and didn't care for the flavor. So in that case the shortening did affect the flavor. So use Crisco if you can. Spectrum might work as well, but I haven't tested it. Update: Spectrum works well!
Use a Scale
For best results, use a digital kitchen scale. This is especially important for getting the amount of cake flour right because the volume measurements can vary by brand and how it's stored. What I do is set the bowl on the scale, set the tare to zero, add 280 grams of cake flour. I then set tare to zero again, add 300 grams sugar and baking powder (measured by volume), then stir well. Once the dry ingredients are blended, I put the bowl back on the scale and just scatter spoonfuls of shortening over it until I get a weight of 96 grams. Then comes the paddle. You get the idea. Using a scale is more accurate and will save you so many measuring cups!
Two-Stage Mixing Method
This white cake recipe uses the two-stage mixing method, which is where you mix the dry ingredients, stir the fat into the dry ingredients to coat, then gradually add liquid and eggs. I always make the cake using a stand mixer and paddle, but a handheld mixer should work too. I think one of the reasons I like this recipe so much is it doesn't involve softening butter.
Frosting
White cake is good with all kinds of frosting, and takes well to fruit fillings. The cake in the photo is frosted with a recipe I named Favorite Vanilla Frosting. I'm not sure it's my absolute favorite anymore, but it's a basic American style buttercream with a lot of vanilla. And it's very good! I've also frosted it with Seven Minute Frosting, but that always seems more appropriate for an Angel Food Cake. This cake needs a frosting with some butter.
Other White and Yellow Cakes
Right now this is one of my favorite white cake recipes because it is actually white, it's not terribly expensive and doesn't involve creaming any butter and sugar. But I have a butter version and will post that soon. If you prefer yellow cakes, I recommend Shirley Corriher's Magnificent Moist Cake or the old Cook's Illustrated Yellow Cake, which also uses the two-stage method. This post has a photo of it, but for that particular cake I used some butternut (now cake batter flavored) extract, which give it an even yellower hue.
Recipe
Square White Cake
Ingredients
- 1 ½ cups cake flour (170 grams)
- 1 teaspoon baking powder
- ¾ teaspoon salt (Morton kosher)
- 3 tablespoons nonfat plain Greek yogurt**
- 1 tablespoon whole milk (14 grams)
- 1 ½ teaspoon vanilla plus ¼ teaspoon almond extract
- 4 tablespoons unsalted butter, softened but still fairly cool (56 grams)
- 3 ½ tablespoons shortening (40 grams)
- 1 cup granulated sugar (200 grams)
- ½ cup egg whites, room temperature (3 large eggs)
- ¼ cup plus 2 tablespoons heavy whipping cream
- 2-3 tablespoons sprinkles (optional)
Instructions
- Preheat oven to 350°F. Grease an 8-inch square metal baking pan.
- Sift the cake flour once, then sift it or whisk it together with the baking powder and salt. Sometimes salt won't go through the sifter, so just stir it in if there's salt left in the sifter.
- Also, mix together the yogurt, milk and extracts in a little bowl and set aside.
- In the bowl of a stand mixer fitted with a paddle, beat the butter, shortening and sugar until creamy. Continue beating, scraping bowl often, for about 5 minutes.
- With the mixer going, gradually add the egg whites in about 4 to 6 additions, scraping the bowl between additions and beating for 20-30 seconds.
- With the mixer on medium low speed or by hand, add the flour mixture and the yogurt mixture in three additions, scraping the side of the bowl. If using a stand mixer, you may find it easier to just remove the mixing bowl from the stand and do this with a heavy duty scraper. If you are not messy with flour, you can dump it in with the mixer going.
- Whip the cream in a separate bowl using a handheld mixer. Fold it into the batter with a heavy duty scraper. Make it a party and fold in some sprinkles! Or skip them. They look pretty in this cake.
- Pour the cake in the pan and drop it on the counter from about ½ inch high (do it twice) to release air bubbles.
- Bake for about 30 minutes or until the cake appears done. It will appear slightly brown on the edges and not be quite as pale in the middle. Let it cool completely in the pan. Frost it in the pan. Alternatively, you can let it cool in the pan for about 10 minutes and turn it out to cool.
Anna says
Good points all around, Cheryl. However, if you see Morton kosher, you may want to give it a try. It measures like table salt and has a cleaner less metallic flavor. The Diamond, which is great for cooking and what chefs use, is harder to find and more expensive. If you are still interested in making a white cake for a special occasion, there's an all-butter version of Silver White Cake here.
https://www.cookiemadness.net/2023/05/13/white-cake-with-butter/
Cheryl Galster says
The ingredients aren’t exactly the same as what one would choose to use today. Like the shortening; I didn’t want to run out for this item or the heavy whipping cream. While it is true that a tub of Crisco shortening would be at home in the 60’s, the same is not found in my home today. Nor is the kosher salt and of all things heavy whipping cream. I was sorry to find that the old Betty Crocker recipes we once loved are now useless to me.
Anna says
I love the White Mountain on Angel Food Cake!
Johnette Beaver says
White mountain frosting with silver white cake is absolutely delicious!! I alway made this for my kids birthdays and they are both grown and still love it!
Anna says
I'll grab that book and try it! Thanks for the recommendation.
Sue says
I think the timing of this post is fascinating since I also recently made a white cake that I loved from Zoe Bakes Cakes. That recipe uses butter, shortening, buttermilk, whipping cream and has vanilla and almond extracts. I was so happy with it how it turned out. You’re probably at the end of your white cake baking for the time being but if you’re not you might give it a try. It was easily the best white cake I’ve ever made.
Anna says
Jen, the other shortening version is on Betty Crocker's site and on Pinterest, where people have posted pictures of it from old Betty Crocker cookbooks. It seems like there are little variations between all of the recipes, but the other shortening version has 2/3 cup of shortening and 5 egg whites. I am happy with this one as far as shortening versions go. The butter version actually has some other major differences. There's 3/4 cup of butter, a litte more baking powder and the whites are folded in last. It's also not as white since it has hte butter. I'll post it soon.
Jen says
This looks amazing! I want to make it with a more traditional strawberry frosting. Are the only things different in the 2nd version are the shortening and egg white amounts? I'd like to try that one